There was no official Freeport High School football team for the 1919 season. The reason given was that a majority of players failed to have the necessary academic average. However, a team was formed independently of the school and called the "Independents."
Source:
| Name |
Position |
| Smith | RE |
| Bedell | RF |
| Firth | RG |
| Canalizo | C |
| Paker | LG |
| Kelley | LT |
| Smith | LE |
| Mahnken | QB |
| Hansen | FB |
| Maxon | RH |
| Spence | LH |
Source:
Freeport 18 Marquand 0 (September 27, 1919)
Freeport 25 St. Francis Prep (October 4, 1919)
Freeport 19 Adelphi Academy 6 (October 11, 1919)
Freeport 40 Port Washington 0 (October 18, 1919)
Independents 19 Aviators 0 (Mitchel Field)
Independents 27 Far Rockaway 0