| Name | Position |
| Mahnken | Left End |
| Firth | Left Tackle |
| Baker | Left Guard |
| A. Jenkins | Center |
| Hansen | Right Guard |
| Maxon | Right End |
| Fussell | Quarterback |
| Spence | Left Half Back |
| E. Jenkins | Right Half Back |
| Milbank | Fullback |
| Loux | Right Tackle |
| Smith | Fullback and Tackle |
| Sloat | Tackle |
Source:
Freeport 26 Adelphi Academy 6 (October 5, 1918)
Freeport 19 Port Washington 7 (Date unknown)
Freeport 19 St. John's Prep 0 (Date unknown)
Freeport 6 Southside 6 (Date unknown)
Freeport 21 Glen Cove 0 (Date unknown)
Freeport 7 Brooklyn Prep 15 (November 16, 1918)
Freeport 0 Southside 9