Source:
| Name | Position | Note |
| Clark | LE | |
| Wiggins | IT | |
| J. Smith | LG | |
| Humphrey | C | |
| Collier | RG | |
| T. Murray | RT | |
| Lynch | RE | |
| Randall | Q | |
| Meaney | LHB/LE | |
| H. Murray | RHB | Captain |
| L. Murray | FB | |
| Elar | RT | |
| Culter | RE | |
| Goller | RG |
Source:
Freeport 6 Hamilton Institute 7
Freeport 0 Adelphi 27
Freeport 0 Curtis 43
Freeport 0 Rockville Centre 0
Freeport 13 Amityville 7
Freeport 25 Alumni 0
Juniors/Freshmen 0 Seniors and Sophomores 46
Source:
The 1912 team had no coach.
Source: